Southern Exposure

wood vs vinyl shutters in fort myers

Wood Shutters Vs Vinyl Shutters

Wood Shutters vs. Vinyl Shutters: Making the Right Choice for Your Home

Choosing the correct type of plantation shutters for your home involves understanding the differences between wood shutters and vinyl shutters. Both options have unique benefits and drawbacks, making them suitable for different environments and preferences. In this blog, we’ll compare wood shutters vs. vinyl shutters to help you make an informed decision.

The Benefits of Wood Shutters

Crafted from natural wood, wood shutters are a standout choice for plantation shutters. They hold their value and bring a timeless, classic appeal to any home. If you’re considering a home upgrade, wood plantation shutters are a fantastic option. It’s worth noting that among all window coverings, plantation shutters are the only treatments that retain their value in full over time.

Wood shutters come in various shapes, finishes, and colors, allowing for extensive customization to match your interior décor. They can be stained or painted to fit any style, from traditional to modern. Additionally, wood shutters are robust and can be repaired, repainted, and refinished, ensuring they last for many years.

The Benefits of Vinyl Shutters

Vinyl shutters can be a great choice if you want to save money or if the shutters will be installed in rooms with high moisture. These shutters have been trendy for a few years, protecting from the heat at a lower cost than wood shutters. When choosing vinyl shutters, there is the standard vinyl and an upgraded vinyl mixed with wood called composite. (Click here to learn more about the different features of composite shutters vs vinyl shutters.)

Vinyl shutters, made from plastic or PVC, are designed to be durable and solid. They excel in high-moisture areas such as bathrooms and kitchens, where wood shutters might be susceptible to damage. Vinyl shutters are also a breeze to clean and require minimal maintenance, making them a practical choice for busy households.

Comparing Wood Shutters vs. Vinyl Shutters

vinyl vs wood plantation shutters

Colors and Finishes:

Wood Shutters: These come in many shapes, finishes, and colors. They can be painted, stained, or refinished to match your home’s style. They are also much easier to repair.

Vinyl Shutters are available in a limited range of neutral shades. Vinyl cannot be painted, stained, or refinished, which limits customization options.


Wood Shutters: Strong and durable but vulnerable to moisture damage. They require regular maintenance, such as sealing and refinishing, to maintain good condition.

Vinyl Shutters: Best choice for high-moisture areas. No matter the humidity or moisture levels, they will not warp or swell. Easy to clean and maintain.

Strength and Durability:

Wood Shutters: Highly robust and durable. Southern Exposure provides premium-quality wood shutters with a UV-protected finish for added durability.

Vinyl Shutters: Durable and resistant to daily wear and tear, temperature fluctuations, and insect infestations. However, they are heavy-weight, flexible, not easy to repair, and subject to UV rot and discoloration over time.

Local Availability

If you’re located in Babcock Ranch, Alva, Naples, or Fort Myers, you can find wood and vinyl plantation shutters that suit your home. Local stores offer various options to meet your needs and provide quality products with long-term guarantees.


When choosing between wood shutters and vinyl shutters, your decision will be influenced by your needs, budget, and preferences. Wood shutters offer timeless beauty, extensive customization, and long-term durability. On the other hand, vinyl shutters provide cost-effectiveness, ease of maintenance, and suitability for high-moisture areas. By partnering with a reputable manufacturer that offers a long-term guarantee, you can ensure you’re making a choice that will enhance your home for years to come.

Frequently Asked Questions About
Wood VS Vinyl Shutters

southern exposures faq window treatment questions

Wood shutters are crafted from natural wood, offering a classic and elegant look, while vinyl shutters are made from synthetic materials, providing durability and affordability. Each option has unique characteristics to consider.

Vinyl shutters are generally more durable than wood shutters, as they are resistant to moisture, humidity, and warping. They are ideal for high-moisture environments such as bathrooms or kitchens.

Yes, wood shutters may require more maintenance, including periodic refinishing or repainting, to maintain their appearance and protect against moisture damage. Vinyl shutters are low-maintenance and easy to clean with soap and water.

Yes, wood shutters are typically more expensive than vinyl shutters due to the cost of natural wood materials and the craftsmanship involved in their production. Vinyl shutters offer a more budget-friendly option.

Wood shutters provide better insulation than vinyl shutters, as wood is a natural insulator that helps regulate indoor temperatures and reduce energy costs. However, vinyl shutters still offer some insulation benefits.

Yes, both wood shutters and vinyl shutters can be customized to match your desired color scheme. Wood shutters can be stained or painted in various colors, while vinyl shutters are available in a wide range of pre-finished colors.

Both wood shutters and vinyl shutters offer excellent light control capabilities. However, wood shutters may provide slightly better light-blocking properties due to the thickness of the material.

Vinyl shutters are more resistant to fading from sunlight compared to wood shutters. Vinyl materials are UV-resistant and do not require repainting or refinishing to maintain their color over time.

While both wood shutters and vinyl shutters can be installed in high-humidity areas, vinyl shutters are better suited for environments with moisture, such as bathrooms, kitchens, or coastal regions, due to their resistance to warping and moisture damage.

Explore our blog for comprehensive articles and guides comparing wood shutters and vinyl shutters, helping you make an informed decision based on your budget, style preferences, and functional needs.

Like Our Post? Share It!

Scroll to Top